14 Cake Recipes For all Skill Levels | Bake or Buy | Milk Bar (2024)

If you're having any issues navigating our site, please email us at help@milkbarstore.com or call us at (347) 577-9504 extension 0

Bakers, this one’s for you. Whether you’re new to dabbling in the kitchen, can confidently tell when your egg whites have reached the perfect “medium peak,” or somewhere in the middle, we’ve got a whole crew of Milk Bar recipes that’ll help you say YES to cake.

These cake recipes are perfect for whatever you’re cooking up this summer––whether that’s lounging poolside, cooling off inside, or preparing for a big get-together. Whip up our Gooey Chocolate Mug Cake or Compost Pancakes whenever your day needs a little à la mode moment. Craving a crumbly breakfast cake to pair with your morning cold brew? Meet our Cake-Mix Coffee Cake. Or maybe you’re ready to go full tropical vibes with our take on the summer cook-off staple, Pineapple Upside Down Layer Cake. Make sure you get your tiki glasses out for that one.

No matter what your taste buds are craving, these recipes will help you push boundaries in your kitchen. Plus, they go really well with creamy, cool Milk Bar ice cream on top ;)

Page Contents

Funnel Cake Cake-Mix Coffee Cake Gooey Chocolate Mug Cake Brownie Cake Compost Pancakes Compost Cookie Tin Angel Food Cake Classic Strawberry Shortcakes The Ultimate Pound Cake Banana Chocolate Hazelnut Cupcakes Gooey Butter Cake German Chocolate Cake Waffles Milk Bar Ice Cream Pints Pineapple Upside Down Layer Cake Spiced Carrot Cake with Graham Frosting Tiramisu Layer Cake Birthday Cake

Beginner Cakes

A no-fuss cake is often just as tasty (if not more) than those fancy-schmancy concoctions behind the glass at a bakery. They’re perfect when you have little time and especially great for the little bakers in your life.

Funnel Cake

Frying up a funnel cake is so easy we wouldn’t be surprised if you started hosting state fairs in your kitchen. Better yet, you can top your funnel cake any way you want: chocolate drizzle, gooey fruit syrup, whipped cream, or keep it traditional with a mountain-sized heap of powdered sugar.

See Recipe

Cake-Mix Coffee Cake

Cake for breakfast. Need we say more? Our fun and simple Milk Bar take on classic coffee cake combines cake mix, sour cream, and your favorite canned, frozen, or pie filling-style fruit to create the perfect pairing for your morning roast. Breakfast cake is already genius. We just made it a little extra.

See Recipe

Goes well with Pie Ice Cream!

Gooey Chocolate Mug Cake

This is mixin-mug-microwave-magic. Like our iconic Compost Cookies, this hot cake breaks all the rules by combining potato chips, ground coffee, chocolate chips, pretzels, butterscotch, and more into two warm personal mug-style servings. It’s gooey yet dense, sweet, and salty. And yes, you’ll never look at your microwave the same way again.

See Recipe

Brownie Cake

It’s a brownie. It’s a cake. It’s BIG dessert energy done in the simplest way. Chewy, fudgy, tender, and light, this recipe brings together our all-time favorite dessert textures. Take your baking skills up a notch with layers of nougat or caramel on top, or go à la mode with an enormous scoop of ice cream. It’s your brownie cake vision. We just want you to embrace it.

See Recipe

Goes well with Chocolate Mint Cookies N' Cream Ice Cream!

Compost Pancakes

These pancakes are where super fluffy springboards of creativity meet the spirit of our Compost Cookie and its cacophony of mixins to create a pantry-inspired breakfast or afternoon snack. Start with our easy pancake base, then go to town with your additions or keep it true to compost form. But there’s only one secret: pancakes are proven to taste way better when you make them in your PJs.

See Recipe

Compost Cookie Tin

You’ve made the pancake, noshed on the mug cake, now try “the one” that started it all. And by one, we mean three. Order a tin of our iconic Compost Cookies, because honestly, you can never have enough sweet and salty treats.

Order Now

Intermediate Cakes

If you’re ready to flex in the kitchen, oh do we have some cakes for you.These recipes call for a few more steps and a smidge of technique, but they’re still do-able desserts that’ll garner plenty of oh wows! from the crowd. Perfect for your summer cook-off, warm night BBQ, or end of school pool party.

Angel Food Cake

Get your bundt pan out for this heavenly dessert dream. Besides its iconic shape and oh-so-fluffy texture, this cake is a canvas for baking exploration. Have fun with different extracts or jazz up your topping with cream, strawberries, blueberries, or go full-on with a glaze. Oh wow, that sounds marvelous.

See Recipe

Classic Strawberry Shortcakes

These shortcakes are “the” legendary shortcakes that launched the dreams of one particular baker into the dessert stratosphere (spoiler: it was our founder, Christina Tosi). These cakes were born from simplicity, a short time span, and easy-to-find ingredients, but they came together as a sweet centerpiece. So go on, show off your baking skills. Bragging rights can be all yours too.

See Recipe

The Ultimate Pound Cake

Pound cake’s cool by itself and all but when you make it ultimate with chocolate, coffee, and pretzels, you’ll never settle for a plain old loaf cake again. This pound cake is inspired by our iconic compost lineup, and forms a sweet yet slightly savory trifecta when paired with our Gooey Chocolate Mug Cake and Compost Pancake recipes. The secret to compost desserts is always more is more, so get ready to raid your panty and have some extra fun.

See Recipe

Banana Chocolate Hazelnut Cupcakes

If you’re ever encountered our Banana Hazelnut Layer Cake and thought, “What? That’s amazing. I want to make it. But into cupcakes. And in fewer steps…” you’re in luck! The mini-version of our wildly-popular layer cake comes down to three components: moist banana cupcake, creamy chocolate hazelnut frosting, and a chocolate crumb garnish. They’ve got the “oh, that’s fancy” look with a “wow, that was manageable” charm.

See Recipe

Gooey Butter Cake

Do you secretly love an undercooked cake? Us too. Now you can make a cake that was made for ooey-gooey lovers–one that goes a step beyond the microwave. Start with a cookie-like crust, then fill it in with a cream cheese-based filling. Bake it up, and voila. No need to hide that gooey cake love anymore.

See Recipe

German Chocolate Cake Waffles

What makes a German Chocolate Cake Waffle German? Honestly, we’re not exactly sure, but we’re a big fan of the ingredients. Cocoa powder and sweetened shredded coconut make these waffles disappear as soon as they’re served. But the real star of the show? The heaping scoop of Milk Bar Ice Cream you’ll put on top. hint, hint

See Recipe

Goes well with Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Ice Cream!

Milk Bar Ice Cream Pints

Want to take your waffles up a notch? Swap the whipped cream for creamy Milk Bar ice cream. Ship our signature flavors like Cereal Milk and Birthday Cake straight to your door or find them at your local Whole Foods, Publix, Ahold, and Target.

Order now

Expert Cakes

Are you ready to get your master apron on and conquer a Milk Bar Layer Cake recipe? We believe in you. These recipes are certified cake projects—elaborate, but the payoff is a beautiful, showstopping cake that will make you wonder if you’re some kind of cake genius. Turns out you definitely are.

Pineapple Upside Down Layer Cake

We love a PUD for its tropical-inspired retro vibes, but our Milk Bar spin takes those party cake feels on a baking quest with layers of coconut cake, maraschino cherry soak, box-cake inspired frosting, and yellow-crumb topping. But the poached pineapple (uh-huh, poached) is what makes this cake-dream super special. Get those tiki glasses out. Both you and this cake deserve a swanky party.

See Recipe

Spiced Carrot Cake with Graham Frosting

All of you year-round Carrot Cake lovers out there—we see you, and we appreciate you. Our carrot cake recipe is a Milk Bar tribute to your CC-love with layers of cinnamon-spiced rounds, velvety liquid cheesecake, white chocolate milk crumb, and graham frosting. Because when mom told us to eat our veggies, we knew she also meant in cake form.

See Recipe

Tiramisu Layer Cake

Tiramisu is the lush, layered genius of Italian desserts. Inspired by Tosi’s Northern Italian roots, this recipe is a special hand-me-down done Milk Bar style. Start with vanilla cake and soak the bejesus out of it with a deep, bitter coffee soak. Then layer with chocolate crumbs, creamy coffee frosting, and—wait for it—fluffy cannoli cream. Celebrate every layer by snacking on some cannoli cream along the way. It’s allowed (and encouraged).

See Recipe

Birthday Cake

If you made it this far, congrats! You deserve a pat on the back and a celebration…with cake, of course. Our iconic Birthday Cake is the perfect celebrate-anytime cake. Get it shipped straight to your kitchen

Don’t forget to share your masterful creations with us on social with the tag #MilkBarRecipe. We can’t wait to see what you bake up! Order Now

14 Cake Recipes For all Skill Levels | Bake or Buy | Milk Bar (1)

GET $15 OFF(YAY)

Sign up for our newsletter and get $15 off your first order of $80+.

By clicking SIGN UP, you agree to receive text messages from Milk Bar at the number provided. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to cancel. View our Privacy Policy.

14 Cake Recipes For all Skill Levels | Bake or Buy | Milk Bar (2024)

FAQs

What does adding more milk to a cake do? ›

One of the main roles of milk in baking is to provide moisture. It can help to keep baked goods from becoming too dry and crumbly, and can also add tenderness to the texture. In addition to adding moisture, milk can also help to create a softer crumb in breads and cakes.

Does Milk Bar cake need to be refrigerated? ›

Our pie and Cake Truffles can be enjoyed at any temperature–you pick! Our cakes can be stored in the refrigerator for up to five days, and up to two weeks in the freezer (cakes should be removed from the fridge two hours before serving). Our cakes are best served at room temperature.

Why is Milk Bar so popular? ›

One of the reasons Milk Bar took off is because it's different. It's different because instead of selling replicas of baked goods that already existed Tosi worked hard to create her own recipes. Tosi did not develop Compost Cookies or Cereal Milk Ice Cream by looking at what everyone else was doing.

Is Milk Bar owned by Momof*cku? ›

(Momof*cku still owns an undisclosed stake in Milk Bar, which operates separately.)

What happens if you add an extra egg to cake mix? ›

Because eggs help build the cake's structure (don't use them and you're looking at a gooey mess), adding an extra egg yolk makes the cake batter denser. Translation: you'll have a moister confection. Conversely, she suggests an extra egg white for a fluffier cake.

What happens to a cake if you use milk instead of water? ›

Yes, you can substitute milk for water when preparing SuperMoist cake mixes, however, the cake may be slightly drier than if prepared with water. Also keep in mind that milk will add calories and change the nutrition slightly.

What cake lasts the longest? ›

Cakes with high sugar content tend to last longer due to sugar's natural preservative properties. Dairy-based cakes, on the other hand, spoil faster due to the perishable nature of dairy products. Similarly, cakes with fruit fillings or toppings also have a shorter shelf life.

What is the shelf life of milk cake? ›

Under ambient conditions, shelf-life of milk cake is generally up to 3–4 days, whereas under refrigeration conditions, it can last up to 12–14 days.

Can you eat 2 week old cake? ›

How to tell if a cake has gone bad or is stale: First, you probably don't want to eat a cake that's over a week old, especially if it hasn't been stored in the fridge. If it's been stored in the fridge, then it still could have gone bad, especially if it has perishable ingredients on it like fruit, custard, curd etc.

What is the Milk Bar controversy? ›

The closure of the Harvard Square location of bakery chain Milk Bar sparked a whirl of controversy this weekend, when employees alleged the company had shuttered its lone Boston-area store to squash a union effort, while corporate officials described the timing as “unfortunately coincidental.”

Was Milk Bar on Shark Tank? ›

"Shark Tank" Episode #10.3 (TV Episode 2018) - Christina Tosi as Self - Founder: Milk Bar - IMDb.

Why is it called Milk Bar? ›

Rather, the milk bar often referred to a venue where proprietors sold milkshakes, which at the time often were comprised of simply milk, ice, and flavoring additives (fruit, chocolate, etc.), shaken till frothy and served in tall glasses.

How many Michelin stars does Christina Tosi have? ›

It is thanks to her great skill as a pastry chef that the restaurant has received 2 coveted Michelin stars.

Why did Milk Bar change Crack Pie? ›

Name change

In May 2019, Devra First of the Boston Globe criticized the name in a column for making light of addiction by alluding to the addictiveness of crack cocaine. The following month, Milk Bar changed the name to Milk Bar pie.

Does Christina Tosi own Milk Bar? ›

Christina Tosi (born 1981) is an American chef and cookbook author. She is founder and co-owner with Momof*cku of Milk Bar and serves as its chef and chief executive officer.

What makes a cake more moist water or milk? ›

One common ingredient swap that is known to help make cakes remarkably moist is using milk instead of water. Try switching out any water in your recipe for full-fat milk or buttermilk for a moist, decadent texture. Another ingredient that can enhance the moisture of your cake is mayonnaise.

Does milk make cake more moist than water? ›

Yes, you may make cakes with milk instead of water. Because fat provides richness and solidity to the cake, milk can increase the cake's moisture content and flavor.

Does adding milk to cake mix make it moist? ›

Baking tip #2: adding milk to your box cake mix in place of water adds a dense texture to your dessert leaving it moist and flavorful like a homemade cake. Or, if you prefer, you can add buttermilk, giving your cake a tangy flavor to balance out the sweetness.

How does milk affect baking? ›

Milk encourages the browning reactions characteristic of baked goods like pastry crusts, cookies and biscuits. Milk contributes to the keeping quality of bread and gives it a soft crust. Additional protein and sugar (lactose) in milk adds more sweetness and a browner color to baked goods than water.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Lakeisha Bayer VM

Last Updated:

Views: 5892

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Lakeisha Bayer VM

Birthday: 1997-10-17

Address: Suite 835 34136 Adrian Mountains, Floydton, UT 81036

Phone: +3571527672278

Job: Manufacturing Agent

Hobby: Skimboarding, Photography, Roller skating, Knife making, Paintball, Embroidery, Gunsmithing

Introduction: My name is Lakeisha Bayer VM, I am a brainy, kind, enchanting, healthy, lovely, clean, witty person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.